The mortgage Zillow calculator has an appealing design and seems like a helpful tool. It promises to calculate your total mortgage payment, including principal, interest, private mortgage insurance (PMI), property taxes, home insurance, and homeowners association fees. It does so, but is the result truly accurate? Read on to learn why. Here are some of the key differences between the three calculators. They should help you determine which one is best for your situation.
Redfin’s mortgage estimate is more accurate
While you might think that redfin’s mortgage estimate is more accurate, the truth is far from it. The redfin mortgage estimate may be off by a few thousand dollars for a property on the market. That said, it’s still an accurate tool to use for mortgage applications. Here are some reasons why. First, the home valuation estimate comes from multiple listing services. These services use this data to make an educated decision about a home’s value.
Second, Zillow and Redfin use outdated data that may not be accurate. For example, your house could be overvalued if you make major additions or renovations since the last appraisal. In such cases, it’s important to hire a real estate agent to get an accurate appraisal. Fortunately, both sites have pricing estimates. They’re also free to use, so you can use them as a guideline.
Trulia’s mortgage estimate is more accurate
While Zillow has the advantage of using real-time data, it lacks valuable information from newly built homes. The Zestimate may be way off if a home has been on the market for a long time. For that reason, it’s vital to consider other factors when comparing the two websites. For example, new homes tend to incorporate better information than those on the market. Also, the estimated sales price of an on-market home may not be reflected in the Zestimate, especially if the home has been listed for a long time. Also, the updating schedule of information may change over time if the new analytical features have been added.
Although both sites claim to be 99% accurate, their estimates can differ significantly. The first, Redfin, operates in 43 states and the District of Columbia. The second, Zillow, uses data from a larger geographic region, pulling information from all counties in a given area. Zillow can’t account for the quality of upgrades made in a home, and its estimates may not be as accurate as Redfin’s.
Zillow’s mortgage estimate ignores PMI
The Zillow mortgage estimate is not an accurate representation of your monthly payments. This estimate doesn’t include property taxes, insurance, or a 20% down payment, so you’ll have to figure those in. Redfin, on the other hand, provides a closer estimate of your monthly payments based on actual data. Although the data for Redfin isn’t always as up-to-date as that for Zillow, it is more accurate and often reflects actual monthly payments.
The Zillow mortgage calculator uses a formula that ignores PMI, HOA dues, and other fees. The formula is designed to give you a rough idea of your monthly payments. Although it relies on publicly available data and market trends, it doesn’t guarantee that your mortgage will be the exact same. Zillow’s mortgage estimate isn’t perfect, but it’s still a useful tool for estimating the monthly payments of your home loan.
Redfin automatically pulls HOA dues from property listing
One major advantage of Redfin over Zillow is that it can pull the homeowner’s association dues from a property listing. While Zillow has a tendency to under-represent homeowners’ association dues, Redfin is more honest, gathering information from reliable sources. The website automatically pulls HOA dues from property listings. It also provides daily updates about the condition of a home.